I was having trouble choosing what to order for myself and my beloved bae, so I called and asked what the three most popular sandwiches were. The employee on the phone stated that the Italian, the Garlic Peppercorn Cheesesteak, and the Starvin' Marvin were the three that came to mind. I ordered the first two, but decided to replace the Marvin with the Sandwich Police because it looked way more interesting.
The Italian is solid. If I were on the go and had to order something from a sandwich shop I'd never been to before, I'd likely order the Italian sub and judge the establishment based on that sub alone. Here it's simple, flavorful, and satisfying as it ought to be.
The Peppercorn Cheesesteak (the one with prime rib) was heaven. Just order it. Really, this should be their flagship. Very few people would not enjoy this sandwich by my estimation. My better half enjoyed his half so much he's made a resolution to go there and get one all for himself some time.
The Sandwich Police was my personal favorite of the three! I love a good mix of savory and sweet, and the tang from the cranberries was so nice and unexpected. I'm definitely getting something with cranberries again, or perhaps one of the sandwiches with pineapple. Thumbs up.