I remember this place being way better when I was in high school, but I'm not sure if the baked good tasted better or if I have greater expectations now. First off, if you're gonna order anything here, order the chocolate macaroons. SO SO SO SO SO SO SO SO SO good. They were good when I was 19, and they're still good at 29. Also, they make a delicious turkey sandwich with cranberry sauce. I bought a blueberry pie here for a coworker - she loved it, but she has no sense of smell, which means her taste buds aren't very reliable. I've personally had way better blueberry pies (Wanda's Pie in the Sky). I order custard tarts here and I seriously had to toss them. So gross. Maybe it was a bad batch?