Whether I'm getting take out or dining in, this place is consistently great. My personal favourite is Cod & Chips with a piece of Key Lime Pie for dessert. If you're getting take out, ask for their home tartar sauce, it's much better than the packaged one they'll normally stick in.
Insanely long line ups on Good Friday and most Friday/Saturday nights. I'd put it in my top two for fish & chips in Toronto.