Just left this place with my wife. We went there based on these excellent reviews and we were very dissapointed. In contrast to the overwhelmingly positive reviews, we found it to be very high prices for very mediocre food.
I had the lamb and my wife had the chicken and shrimp, both were edible but bordered on terrible to just plain bland (my wife had to put salt and pepper on the chicken just to give it some incling of recognizable seasoning).
Ive had much better lamb in gyros in our home town of Janesville that run around 5 bucks... so this lamb priced as a 35 dollar plate being far worse was quite a shock. Avoid this place, and instead spend your money on one of the many great restaurants that surround it.