3.5 stars.
Comfortable, unhurried atmosphere, with friendly servers and good breakfasts. It's been a few weeks, so I don't remember the details, but remember thinking it would be worth a return visit.
edit; Just went back (a few months later) and remembered a point I wanted to make. Potatoes don't come with the standard breakfast, but you can add an "an order of" hash browns, which is a McDonalds-style pre-formed patty. Once you've accepted that, it's not bad. They also charge for coffee refills. Including the hash browns and two refills, it was still under 8 bucks.