A meal at Sitara always takes me back to my visits to the English countryside. The Empire's relationship to India has left the British homeland with at least one Indian restaurant in seemingly every village I traveled through. A local friend warned me that I shouldn't frequent an Indian restaurant if it happens to be the only choice in town (that advice turned out to be quite accurate as I unfortunately discovered). Let's just say those solitary waysides would not likely survive in Soho.
So although Sitara doesn't really have much competition locally, it really is a wonderful find for authentic Indian cuisine. I generally like the lunchtime special, a non-vegetarian thali. It is like a little smorgasbord of spicy treats with a sampling of curries, tandoori chicken, pakora, and naan and rice. Seasoning tends to run on the mild side though I imagine you could ask for some adjustments if you prefer a bolder flavor. I observed mostly empty plates returning to the bussing station so I'm speculating that most of the customers are enjoying their food as I did.
Service is unremarkable but competent. The host can be charming when he wants to be but don't hold your breath expecting it. Prices are inexpensive for the portion sizes. If you have a taste for something on the exotic side, I think Sitara fills the bill. Recommended.