I'm only giving this place a three stars for their super tasty Nutella and peanut butter cup martinis. Those are the only things I've found remotely delicious out of everything I've had here.
Service is always lacking. I think the management is also super rude. I came in last night for my birthday with three other people and was told there was a two hour and forty five minute wait when half of the restaurant was empty, so I gave the manager my name and he put me on the "wait list." I didn't care too much because I wanted to bar hop on East 4th anyway, and figured we'd come back when our table was ready.
I came back and got the martinis I love and this time I ordered the strawberry "plate" that has a martini glass filled with chocolate to dip it in. They only give you six strawberries and a huge martini glass filled to the brim with chocolate and charge you $9!! ABSURD.
I definitely feel this place is overhyped, and the food I've ordered prior to last night was mediocre at best. If you just want a martini definitely check this place out, but don't come with high expectations!