After hearing so much hype about the rivalry between Mineo's and Aiello's, I was expected to be blown away by our meal. On the contrary, I was extremely disappointed. We had a group of 6 and were quickly seated at a large round table by the window. Our server was very nice and suggested that we wait a little to order drinks since we were there just before happy hour. I always appreciate someone looking to help us save a few bucks!
The wings that we ordered to share were very good. Huge in size, cooked very well and great flavor. Unfortunately, I can't say the same about the pizza. The pizza was half mushroom and onion and half pepperoni and onion. There were about 5 times as many onions as there needed to be. The pizza was also not cooked nearly enough, so a sea of cheese fell off as you tried to pull a slice of pizza from the tray. I never thought I could possibly complain about too much cheese, but it happened. I had to try to eat it with a knife and fork because it was so moist and soft. We didn't even take the leftover pizza with us.
I hope this was a one-time mistake, but I won't be very likely to go back for pizza.