Went with the Big Daddy cup or whatever it's called...
Tried a few flavors of gelato (salted caramel, coffee that I found too potently bitter) before settling in on chocolate chip. None of them were as smooth as I'd wanted.
For my macaroon I chose vanilla - it was the best part of the cup!
I was most excited about a toasted marshmallow on top, but it tasted salty and wasn't gooey all the way through because it's only toasted with a blow torch. Neat trick but it didn't live up to my expectations.
Also, the whole thing is tough to eat with the spoon they give. I ended up taking off the marshmallow, and using the macaroon as my spoon.