I cannot afford to eat at the Hyeholde on my own but my company has our yearly holiday party there and I'm happy to eat & drink on the boss' dime.
Every drink I've tried has been yummy and the food is incredible. The portions are small but everything is pretty rich so you couldn't eat a huge portion. Their dressing that they use on their mixed green salad is amazing, I believe they sell bottles of it.
The atmosphere is really cool...rustic and they have fireplaces going in the winter. Just a really neat place if you're celebrating something special.