Papa John's Pizza is good, not great. I do like the pepperccinis they include with each pizza. I will say I was pleasantly surprised by how good the wings are and order those pretty often.
The best part about Papa Johns though is the app. It has all local specials listed and you earn points for ordering which add up to a free pizza. There are a lot of really cheap specials, particularly tied to Indians or Browns games, so I find it to be a good value. Plus you can track your pizza as its being made and know when it's on the way for delivery.