Writing this review is a struggle. Two stars is a bit harsh, three stars a bit generous. It's not that this place is bad, but given Toronto's current obsession with craft beer and local breweries it's pretty disappointing. Here's why.
The place itself could use a rethink from a design perspective. It just feels cold and devoid of any character. I think someone else noted this in their YELP review previously. The guys working were nice enough, but for some reason, during the entire night we seemed to be in a blind spot (we were seated at the 4 top by the door). The server would literally walk to the tables surrounding us on all 3 sides (the 4th side being the door) and bypass us. At best the brewery was 1/3rd full at it's peak so no idea what the deal was.
We ordered some appetizers to share which consisted of the cheese and charcuterie platter and some pickled eggs. The cheese was good, but the charcuterie was cut in such massive thick slices that I just couldn't eat it. I know some people like this rustic style, but it's just not for me as it's way too much chewing and gets stuck in your teeth.
Beer-wise - they have an ok selection, but nothing stood out that would make me go out of my way to return and I actually don't recall if they had anything exclusive to them. Overall, my experience reflected the quality and level of service - indifferent.
Would I return? *shrugs shoulders*
Would they care if we did? Probably not.