The old fashioned here is very special (well since it's in the restaurant name) and truly delicious. They crush an orange peel and cherry together with the sugar and bitter, which is kinda unique from all the old fashioned recipes I tried online. It's a little sweet but I really like it!! The hot dog is delicious too, with the true texture of meat (not some lousy starchy flavor). We also ordered onion rings and cheese curds, portion size is very Wisconsin. My second favorite American restaurant in Madison!