Not much to add to the many praises Yelpers have written. The seating felt cramped for the prices they charge but the freshness and flavor of my food helped me forget about all that. The service was pleasant as expected but nothing spectacular. It's a special place in an unusual venue. It has a hip, trendy feel and the food is memorable.
The Trottola I ordered was delicious but the portion was too large. I was traveling so taking out leftovers was not an option. Enjoyable experience and a place I would return to again - if I can find it! Guaranteed that first timers like me will have difficulty finding the place. Perhaps that adds to the allure of Cenacolo.