I've only had great times at the Lodge. It's very versatile; you can have fun at happy hour (shooting darts, watching sports, playing pool, cornhole) and even better time at night. The staff is great and do their best with such a packed house. Very fairly priced and always has a pretty good crowd on the weekends. The crowd is more laid-back than some of the surrounding clubs.
The bartenders are very nice too. I've left my credit card there countless times (my fault) and they always keep it safe and of course laugh at me when I come in on Sunday to get it.