Ok... I've been to this place about 10-15 times now, and each and every time, I am served piping hot slices (they're made fresh, not cut out of an existing pizza.... Who makes pizza by the slice fresh?!), with toppings that I want, all within 10 or so minutes. And the pizza is always delish. And $4 gets you 2 slices (also called half a friggin medium sized pizza) with a drink (or 3 for $5).
And the best part of it all? Just shout "Bada Bing!" as you walk in, and you get a buck off a whole Pie.
This place truly deserves 5 stars, and is thus being upgraded... :D