What they lack in atmosphere they more than make up for in food quality and value. Most of the ingredients are locally sourced and there is a great beer selection and a concise assortment of wine. The vegetable rolle is amazing - perfectly al dente pasta and a savory combo of alfredo and marinara sauces. I don't recall what I had on my first visit but it was good enough to bring me back a year later.
I make sure to eat here every time I am in Madison and you should too.