My husband and I came back here for burgers on a Sunday night. Here's my rundown:
-Service-5 stars, our server was friendly, attentive and prompt.
-Atmosphere-4 stars, cozy bar atmosphere
-Food-3 stars, Good but not great by my Madison burger standards
-Price-3 stars, A little over the top for what it is (pretty sure the meat is just conventional), everything is a la carte so a burger with fries can put you over $12-14.
-Payment-1 star, They only accept cash and check, the ATM charges a $2 fee. Honestly this really annoys me because it is the servers who end up paying for it. We left a good tip but I know a lot of people are not going to want to after being charged $2 plus whatever their bank charges just to get $$ to pay for dinner. Honestly I think it is a greedy policy and they should change it (or do what Jennifer street market does and refund the ATM fee for those who need to use the ATM). Their servers deserve better.