3.5 stars....
1. I had the Madison sandwich. It is just an average sized sandwich grilled in a panini press. The chicken on the sandwich was moist and flavourful, but the sandwich was a bit on the salty side overall.
2. At 10$ out the door, the sandwich was on the pricey side. A cup of soup "combo" pushed things closer to 14$ before any drinks are added.
3. There is really nowhere to sit here, perhaps 4 seats. The people who come here to sit are generally the same folks who love to sit for over an hour pretending to be clueless or the Queen of the Annex while others trudge out into the snow to eat.
4. Service here is decent for what it is.
In conclusion, this is a good (not great) sandwich that is a bit overpriced in a small space where you are best served getting your meal to go. Nothing was bad, yet nothing about the experience made me feel in a hurry to return.