I have been debating whether this place is good or not, and I think I've finally figured out why I just can't get a feel for it.
I think Papa George is supposed to be an upscale place since its prices are comparable to Olive Garden and Biaggis ($9.69 patty melt; $11.85 lunch serving of spinach pie (spana...)), but with smaller portions. Yet its online specials include an entree + 6-pack of beer. (What upscale restaurant advertises six-packs of beer?) I also have a hard time separating the place from Pickles, and its location among blue-collar shops takes away from the restaurant's possible sophistication. So every time I go, I expect lower prices and/or bigger portions than what actually happens.
The food is not bad, but it is not great either. It's a place that you would not mind eating at if your friends asked you to, but you would never go there by your own decision. I think it's just poor execution of the restaurant's concept, which makes me sad because the owners and staff are nice and deserve to do well there.