Great job Yelp! We visited this location because of the reviews.
The appetizers 5 stars: We tried the Hummus Shawarma, Labneh, and Eggplant El Rahib. They were awesome. The fresh bread that came with it was exquisite. Although on our second visit, the over was down and we didn't have fresh pita bread. Get a second over because the fresh pita bread is a strong selling point.
The meals went from 3.5-5 stars. The Kebab was ok. I would give it 3.5 stars. The lamb special on the other hand was amazing and deserves a 5. Unfortunately they don't have that all the time. We had some of their sandwiches as well and they were around 4 stars.
On average I would give it a 4-4.5 stars, but I bumped it to 5 because they are consistently good.