After seeing that their corporate office noticed my review and promised to speak to the workers regarding their past behavior towards customers I decided to give the store another chance.
Earlier this month I went it to purchase two gift cards: one for a newborn girl and one for a little toddler girl. I noticed that the store only had two types of cards on display: one that was gender neutral and one for little boys. I would've purchased the gender neutral card, but both were going to the same family and I didn't want the parents to be confused about which card went to which little cousin. I asked the manager if they had any other designs to choose from and without hesitation she enthusiastically searched around until she found two brand new designs - one of a little toddler girl and one with cutesy zoo animals. They were perfect!
The manager and the sale associates on the floor were a welcoming crew and I left the store eager to return :)