I'm an ASU student and I go here every time my parents are in town. NEVER HAD ONE BAD THING!
The pasta is amazing, the meatball sandwich is awesome, never had a bad appetizer. The half baked cookie is out of this world. But the deep dish, OH MY GOD! The best pizza I have ever had, hands down! Cuts like piece of pie. If you're a meat lover, get the deep dish with pepperoni, sausage and meatballs. it's what my dad and I get and it is just amazing!
All of this added on to a funky place, friendly staff and amazing atmosphere and you have a huge winner!
Highly recommend!