I chose to rate Mary Yoder's "Amish" Kitchen a two because Mary might be a tad distressed to see her name attached to this restaurant.
First of all I've never had to follow so many rules just to eat. Don't substitute that, don't share that, can't eat that with that. I thought the Amish were a peaceful people but I was afraid I'd be taken out in irons if I didn't follow the rules.
Many dishes are not homemade and the turkey was a processed breast brought to the restaurant. Veggie burger was boxy burger. The cost seems high for food that is not all homemade.
Now, I had the homemade chicken salad on homemade bread and the bread and chicken salad was very tasty. The rolls and apple butter are also good. If indeed it was all homemade then that was some decent fare. Mashed potatoes and mac and cheese were good and were also advertised as home made.
The place was clean and the staff was friendly. I just am not sure the prices and hype justify the restaurant.