I want to like this place, I really do, but seriously folks it just doesn't deserve 5 stars. The displays were charming but the selection of both candy and toys was very limited and overpriced. If you want some really unique kids stuff at a great locally owned store try Garage on Stetson or Zoolikins on 5th Ave for the younger ones. And Yuri's popcorn a couple miles north on Scottsdale Rd has a some more authentic old school candy.
I guess I was just expecting someplace like Sweeties in Chandler that has just about every type of candy you can think of. For whatever reason Old Town Candy & Toys just fell flat for me. But an extra star any way since it is nice to have something besides a snobby gallery, douchey bar or lame Mexican place in Old Town.