You don't need to be a hipster to enjoy this dive bar. They kept the old Elk's Lodge sign at the entrance and just rolled with the wood-paneling in the bar area, so they aren't taking themselves too seriously. I may be a closet hipster, but I arrived to the bar looking like a schoolmarm in my work clothes. The bearded dudes in flannel and the tattooed bartender didn't give me a second glance... they just assumed I'd want a cocktail list instead of a beer list. Once I corrected them, all was smooth sailing from there.
The draft list is short, but quality. They have a beer for every taste. I adored the Hop Farm Provision Saison recommended to me by a friend - has a very subtle hint of flavor that makes for a wonderful aftertaste. It was also $3 draft night, which really can't be beat.
Loved their pizza and love that it can be ordered by the slice. When your favorite pizza topping is anchovies it is difficult to get the haters to allow the salty little gems atop the cheese where they belong, so pizza by the slice becomes a delicacy. The crust reminded me of my beloved Beto's pizza, sturdy and with a soul-satisfying crunch! The sauce was not a dominant flavor, which is another quality that makes me weak in the knees. Quality cheese and salty anchovies slightly melted against that already delectable base and you've got one excellent slice of pizza. I only wished I had ordered more!