Oh what to say about this place? I have been wanting to come here for years and years, essentially since the Cosmo opened and never did because the lines were always so long which only drove me to want to go there more because of how good it must be. Luckily I had a concert here the other day and had enough time beforehand to go and grab some of their 'za with a friend of mine. I guess the easiest way to go from here is a pros and cons list.
Pros:
Quality ingredients
In the Cosmo which in and of itself is a pro
Nice staff
The pizza actually tasted pretty good, not amazing as others have stated, but pretty good
Cons:
Super pricey, especially if you are hungry. At least $5.25 per slice? That's extreme. Whole pizza for $35? Not the worst I've seen but still outrageous. Now, the stupid thing is if you want to make a whole pizza out of 8 random slices, they charge you by the slice which I honestly get but was still in shock a bit.
Drinks are pricey, just like everywhere else in the Cosmo. $4.25 for water and $10 for a tall beer.
Really long line and wait, easily 40 minutes, even if you want just a slice.
They heated our pizza up back in the oven but not long enough so the majority it was lukewarm.
For all of the hype that I have heard about this being the best pizza in the state and the best pizza people have ever had, I was really disappointed. I will not be going back and I suggest that people try other places and expand their palates. I get that everybody has their own opinions but there is better pizza out there and for a way cheaper price.