I'd give this a true 3.5, but am rounding up in good faith. I walked in to get an iced cake for a going away party. I knew I might have to sacrifice quality because I didn't place a call-ahead order.
The cake was delicious--icing was creamy and not too sweet. I was happy there were about 5 different pre-made cakes I could choose from: vanilla, chocolate and marble in pink, blue and green styles. Workers were friendly and helpful. (Lady said the burnt almond torte was a customer favorite so I'll be back to try!)
What I was disappointed with was the icing job. Felt like I could have done a better job with spacing and lettering than the worker who helped me. She may have been inexperienced but I expect someone working at a bakery to at least be able to write the basics. Feel like it ruined an otherwise lovely cake.
There was a wide selection of cookies, cakes (large and individual sizes) and fresh-baked donuts. I'll be back to try more from this local bakery, just be wary about getting cakes iced on the spot!