Yelp got the best of me. Went to this place based on the dominant 5 star reviews and even went for the Fisherman's Platter!! Shared a haddock and the fries with my girls and nothing remained to take home. The fried shrimps were succulent. Unimpressed with the fried scallops, haddock, and halibut which is 80% of the order. Aunty Mary's at Scarborough Golf Club Rd and Lawrence, Scarborough still is #1 for halibut in my books.