Although the spices here will not blow you away, the prices are reasonable and you will leave satisfied and happy with the meal. I am glad to have this place in Madison. When I lived in LA, I frequently went to Boiling Crab or to the Boiling Crab imitators; this place is not as good, but holds its own.
I tried the all spices on a pound of shrimp and garlic butter on some mussels. Both were pretty good! I recommend you add on sausage, it is really tasty!
Give this place a shot. It does not deserve the low ratings it has gotten! It is NOT traditional, Louisiana-style Cajun food. It is more Asian inspired (you can order white rice or edamame as a side) and is good at what it does.