the few times I've been here, it has been memorable. So, I have to give it a five. They will fill your growler with any beer without a hassle (vs. Otto's in State college, which is a 3). The cask ale selection was quite narrow, in that they only had one or two, but at least they have it. The food has been good in the past. they would be a 6 with lower prices.
I think they would do better and be happier with slightly lower prices, more sales, and more buzz , more turnover of beer, and a more stable business model that way. But, then it would be more crowded.