I had a really lovely time at Anthony's. The service was excellent (though it could have been since we were one of only 2 tables occupied when we got there at 6:00 on a Wednesday). We never had to wait more than a few seconds for a refill, more cheese, napkins, etc.
The menu is pretty vast with a good selection that would make anyone happy. I am super indecisive so I had the waiter choose between a few options for me, and I ended up with the chicken piccata. It was full of flavor and the chicken was very tender... Would definitely recommend it. We also had calamari as an appetizer, and it was perfectly cooked... Not rubbery like some places. For dessert, we had cannoli which were amazing! The crispy shell was obviously fresh and the cream was sweet without being overpowering.