I have never been to New York, so I have no idea what a pizza from there should taste like. With that being said, the slice of pie I had from NYP was pretty dam tasty.
Thin crust, zesty sauce, tasty toppings, and herbs -- what more could you want?! I was also glad that I ordered some garlic knots, because of the spicy kick, and the delicious dipping sauce they came with.
Next time I'm in Vegas, I will be back here for sure.