Service: Spot on for how busy it was-my glass was never empty and we were seated IMMEDIATELY which we did not expect based on the line out the door. Our food came fast at a lunch rush and our waitress was very helpful explaining what was popular on the menu.
Atmosphere: Weird little layout, but very homey, a place you want to keep drinking and eating for an extended period of time; you will want to come back.
Food: THE BEST CHEESECURDS EVERRRR. EVER. I am a cheese curd fanatic (who isn't from the state of WI), and I have never wanted to shove cheese into my mouth as quickly as I did last summer with my boyfriend when we stopped in here. The breading is so light, you really get to appreciate the flavor and texture of the cheese. We ordered both kinds, the goat cheese and the regular. I would order those goat cheese curds every day and dedicate my waistband size to sweatpants if I lived in Madison. The bloody mary was spot on-I could eat a whole jar of their homemade pickles. The grilled cheese with bacon was crispy on the outside and ooey-gooey on the inside, just like I like it.
Whenever I find out a friend or relative is heading in this direction I always recommend this fantastic establishment. I should have wrote this review sooner to give my praises.