I do not hesitate to declare Alchemy the best Friday Fish Fry in Madison. I've tried Toby's ... I've had Dexter's ... and Alchemy is my favorite, hands down. You get 4 good size pieces of cod, with a golden, fluffy breading. It comes with green beans or fries, coleslaw and a roll, for about $12.50. Oh and I almost forgot their make their own gourmet tartar sauce here too -- it doesn't come straight from a jar. If fried fish was healthier, I'd eat here every Friday.
I just realized I recently reviewed Alchemy, but after having their fish last week and visiting other restaurants that were supposedly the "best" in Madison, I felt I had to come back and review their fish again.