This is my family's go to in the Tempe/Chandler area. We have been going her since their original location down in Chandler for over 10 years now.
They have great lunch specials (one of their entrees for $8.95, it is set for each day of the week) & the food is very reasonable for what you get. I don't believe there is any food item over $15 on the menu. They also have an incredible rewards program, believe you get something free after every 5th meal.
All the entrees start with their house salad. If you don't like their salad, you clearly don't like eating. It is a Italian dressing with cut up salami & cheese. It blows away most house salads I have ever had. Their bread has a great crust on it. For entrees, they have a great standard chicken Parmesan with an excellent cut of chicken. Their pork chops are very juicy and tasty, but not huge. If you are hungry I would suggest doing the double order, unless you want to fill up on salad. They have excellent build your own pizza's (they are decent size) as well. Finally dessert...when I do get one, I get the spumoni. It is a gellato style spumoni. This is the only one I have had, but the other desserts have looked really tasty.
It is not the fanciest restaurant, but it has a nice atmosphere. I would say it is a 4-1/2, but I give them a benefit of the doubt since we have never had a bad experience there.