I give it 4 stars because it has some unique items (spices, condiments, non-toxic cleaning products) that are worth stopping in for. They also have pork roll, which as a Jersey girl, I appreciate.
The prices for some things are a bit high.
Otherwise, most of the stuff (bakery, seafood bar) seems to be shipped in and not prepared fresh there.
Their organic produce seems priced ok, maybe not as cheap as Trader Joes, but they do have a bit more variety and it's not all bagged.
Their crispy cookies and brittle are wickedly good.