Atmosphere: Great! It felt cozy and reminded me of a pub.
Service: Attentive and helpful. I was also super impressed with the service at the bar - when I asked about Italian wines he ended up giving me a tasting of 5 wines and a lesson about wine to boot!
Food: Just so-so. The pizza has a very thin, crispy crust and I thought it tasted dry. Some people at my table liked the pizza though so I think it's just a matter of opinion. I also wasn't a fan of the caponata - the onions in it were raw and I didn't like finding out there were raisins in it after I ordered it. The lemon cheesecake was delicious though!