If I was rating just based on what else can be found in a couple blocks circumference I'd go higher, but this is Montreal, you can walk, bixi, stcum your way to all kinds of fun. This place has nice atmosphere, but on the plain side, aside from the one chandelier made from wine glasses. Dim and romantic though. Perched on the couch on the second floor tasting wines and eating cheese and charcuterie I'm quite happy, don't get me wrong, and I totally love the staff here. It just doesn't swoon and thrill me somehow. But I'll definitely be back!