I arrived at Pepper's slightly before 5pm and there was already a small crowd forming outside the door. We were seated right away and placed an order for a medium pizza, fried calamari, and baked manicotti. The staff was extremely friendly and checked up on us often. About four different people came up to our table to make sure we were okay and the food was good. The calamari was nothing special. The sauce was thin and the breading was mediocre. The pizza (medium deluxe) was ginormous. It easily could have fed about 3-4 people, and was rich with lots of toppings and good stuff. Needless to say, I only had a couple of slices before throwing in the towel. The baked manicotti came out hot and piping, but it wasn't seasoned very well and lacked flavor. The staff was amazing and very friendly, and the food is okay. Not a bad spot! I'd definitely go back again.