Two & a half stars. I feel bad giving this place a bad review because the old man owner seemed like a nice guy just trying to have a restaurant, but the bottom line is that the prices are a bit too high for food that is just good.
The service was friendly, the beer selection was good, and there are multiple options for vegetarians which is pretty fantastic. I had the portobello mushroom and I love that I could choose fresh garlic and goat cheese as topping options. The garlic basil aioli that came with my burger was awesome - full of delicious pesto flavor. The bun is big and buttery. The fries have to be ordered separately, and they are good, but not $6 good. My fiance had the BBQ Burger and he said it was fine - not out of this world good but fine.
Just overall my gut feeling is that it's a little too much to spend on a burger and fries. I'd have been just as happy with an in-n-out burger for a whole lot less.