Update: we went again last night and again it was so so good!! The service was ON POINT this time. I think our severs name was Jasmine and she was excellent.
We had the small cheese and a personal pepperoni with buttercrust and a small cookie for dessert because we are ALL the pizza. This was the perfect amount for two hungry people.
The wait was about 40 minutes but they have a very nice text/web based "waiting" system which was really appreciated, if you aren't going to take reservations a system like this makes waiting much much nicer because you can walk around a bit and get out of the crowd until you get close. Love this place!
Get the buttercrust and save room for the cookie!!!!!