I came here based on the help ratings but I do not understand why it earned 4.5 stars. I must have missed something.
Food:
I ordered their most popular breakfast, the chicken fried steak. The steak, itself was decent but the gravy was thin and tasteless (tasted and looked canned.) The 2 eggs on the side were overcooked. The yolks were runny as I asked but the whites were cooked brown, dry, and rubbery. The potatoes were also tasteless. They were probably purchased frozen and reheated.
Service:
Service was good initially. We were seated quickly, we have our drink orders, and then our food orders quickly. Then, after our food arrived the server gave my wife and I second glasses for our drinks (took up slot of room on our table.) I did not realize at the time but this indicated that we would never see her again.
Our drinks ran dry by no refill came. You pay at a register up front so I never saw her again.
Ambiance:
Decorations were fun and comfortable. No mistaking this was the Hoosier Cafe because pennants and jerseys were hanging wall to wall.