We came here on a personal recommendation (and... after reading Yelp reviews) - and am I ever glad we did.
With great (American style) coffee, a small but wonderful tea collection, fabulous sandwiches (for breakfast and lunch) and a beautiful selection of pastries, as well as some fresh bread, I can see why this place gets consistently great reviews. They also have specialty coffees, though we didn't try any.
I had a smoked trout sandwich and the Tempered Room specialty tea mix. Both were delicious! Hubby had the (bacon) breakfast sandwich and was enthusiastic about it. I had a bite and it was delicious. He was also very satisfied with his coffee - and I had a sip of that and I can see why.
A great solution for a narrow space was provided along the wall by the cash, with built in tables and stools where two people could perch to eat, or one person with a laptop could be very productive. A coat rack at the front ensure you didn't need to feel crowded by winter clothing in the limited space. Community seating at the front of the house is perfect for those of us that thrive on being surrounded by others. The feel is light and comfortable with beautifully (and we think authentically) aged walls and exposed brick.
Staff were great and answered all of our questions.
Would I return: Yes. This will become a regular stop for us when we are in town.
Would I recommend: Yes, enthusiastically to those that love sandwiches and pastries. :-)