I eat here once or twice a month. Never been disappointed by the food or the service. The place is on the smaller side and more intimate than most restaurants.
Appetizers I have had and recommend:
Stuffed Jalapenos
Enchiladas Verde-I typically eat this as an entree
Lighter fare:
Burgers are good
Cowboy stew was good and comforting
Main Meals
Buttermilk Chicken with sweet potato mash-excellent
Red Chili over rice and beans-nice
Central Chicken was very nice
Desserts
Buttermilk pie-worth going for by itself
Bread Pudding-Best in the Valley hands down
Chocolate Souffle-nicely done, has a little chili in it for a nice kick
Service:
Typically all have been excellent
Kelton is the perfect mix of friendly but not overpowering
The place is very casual and friendly in feel. Someplace you can drop in for a nice meal and not break the bank. Better food that the Roaring Fork at a fraction of the price and much friendlier.