I have eaten here many times and never been disappointed. The pizzas are incredible. Try one with topped with fresh basil the owner grows himself - superb.
The pastas are also among the best I have enjoyed anywhere in the world, including Italy.
This is true, homemade Italian cooking. If that's not your thing, don't bother.
It seems people like to complain about the wait. I've never been bothered by it, maybe 30 minutes tops. Which is what I expect a freshly prepared meal to take.
Order some wine, have a freaking conversation. If you need your food in ten minutes, there is a table waiting for you at the Olive Garden.