I have eaten at the Leslieville location a couple of times and learned some very valuable lessons. At first glance the menu does not look too expensive, but you'll end up ordering several things in an attempt to satisfy your lobster craving. The best valued item on the menu is the lobster roll (I ordered the warm one). With a healthy dose of hot sauce, this sandwich is delicious and you actually get a lot of lobster in it! This is contrasted to the other very enticing items on the menu including the lobster poutine and lobster mac and cheese- delicious in theory, doesn't work on the plate. The cheese in both dishes totally overpowers the lobster to the point that you can't even taste it! You're left with the sad feeling wishing you'd saved your hard-earned dollars and had regular poutine from the truck down the road. The other dish I'd recommend is the jerk crab- really tangy, spicy, and flavourful.
Overall, this is a pretty cool place to grab some drinks (highly recommend the over-priced but worth it Caesar) and a lobster roll. Don't be a fool and fall for the other menu items- I have done it twice now and I'm left with an empty wallet and a serious craving for lobster.