Went for my friends birthday.
When my friend first told me that this is where we were going, I was a bit confused by the concept, but whatever. So off we went.
Firstly, reservations appear to be a must. My friend smartly had one and we had to get there at 6:30 even though the pianos only started at 9:00. There's an $11 cover charge which kind of sucks but it's a business.
We started off by eating. I had both the potato skins and the deep fried pickles. The potato skins weren't anything to write home about but the pickles were pretty good.
For drinks, just buy the pail thing that they offer which is a shooter and another drink and a bunch of ice because the money to size ratio is pretty good. Plus it looks pretty awesome when your entire table has them. I got asked twice what was up with our pails by various people.
The pianos were AMAZING. Our group tipped $50 (pooled together) and we handed them a stack of at least 10 songs. We therefore were treated to a medley that consisted of the Spiderman theme, Shake it Off, Stop from the Spice Girls, Wrecking Ball and Paradise City and it strangely worked. The piano players are on their game and I don't think there isn't a song they couldn't do. We also tipped for Danger Zone by Kenny Loggins and ended up with the entire soundtrack from Top Gun. It was pretty fun just to have a drink (or pail or two) and sing obnoxiously loud at the top of your lungs. They have you get up and stand on your chairs as the night goes on so be warned for that. Everyone was so into it and was having a great time.
Our server Megan was also amazing. I haven't been to a restaurant where they take the time to learn your name and then call you by it the entire time.
The only problem was that it was SO expensive. I spent over $100 inbetween food, drinks and tipping.
Tipping will make sure your song gets played, but I think they play the others too.