Walking in, an ordinary person (and to be honest-even me) would think it's your average dive bar but supposedly to locals in mentor- it's an end all be all. I was here for a friends birthday party and I was shocked to see how everyone knew each other. I've never seen anything like it where anyone that comes in through the door, people knew on a first name basis. Waitresses knew kids because they were cafeteria lunch ladies at school. It was actually really nice seeing the close knit community. With a big crowd, the waitresses made sure to come around a few times to get our food and drink orders in even as newcomers were joining. Food came out quick nonetheless and was really good. Not your average bar food choice, I ordered the chicken parm and the chicken was cooked perfectly. There was just enough marinara sauce where it wasn't soaked and wasn't dry. The atmosphere in general is great with good music, a jukebox, and a pool table to kill some time. The city of mentor is doing quite well for themselves with having Spuddy's in town.