Upsides: Their beer and beer alternatives were great and they had a good selection. I liked that they carried Koffee Klosh, Not Your Dad's Rootbeer, and a myriad of ciders.
They do have an old school Nintendo set up on a small table with all of the old Nintendo games. Nothing like womping your boyfriend at Dr. Mario! The board game selection was OK. Mostly older games but a few newer. Most for 4+ players.
Downsides: The set up is a bit haphazard and unkempt at times, looks kind of like a nerdy basement with odd and mismatched furniture with sticky surfaces. Not awesome when you're trying to play tabletop games and the table has not been cleaned at all. Some consoles work and some don't.
However. I am sure with a larger party it would have been a bit more epic.